TAVR Valves – Which Valve is better?


Aortic valve is the valve between the left ventricle and Aorta. With progression of age and age-related wear and tear this valve can get narrowed. This narrowing of aortic valve is called Aortic Stenosis.

This progressive narrowing of aortic valve and once it reaches a critical number it is called severe aortic stenosis. People with severe aortic stenosis especially if they have symptoms tend to have sudden death and more complications. This is the reason why people with severe symptomatic aortic stenosis need to have the aortic valve replaced. So this procedure is called aortic valve replacement. There are no medicines for this narrowed aortic valve because it is a mechanical problem. It is not a problem that can be reduced with medicines.

Patients with severe aortic stenosis especially if they have symptoms tend to have complications and even sudden death. So this condition demands an early aortic valve replacement.


Aortic valve replacement can be performed

TAVR procedure and choice of valves:

TAVR valves are of two types:

  • Balloon expandable valve

Balloon expandable valve

  • Self-expanding valve

Self expanding valve

In India both these types of valves are available from different manufacturers.

Balloon expandable valve types:

Edwards valve: The first balloon expandable valve was developed by the Edwards Company where you have got the Edwards 3 model of the valve. So this is a first prototype of the balloon expandable valve. The Edwards valve is manufactured in United States.

MyVal: The alternative one which is manufactured in India is the MyVal which is also a balloon expandable valve similar to that of the Edwards valve.

Self-expanding valve types:

In the self-expanding valves there is no balloon. The valve expands on its own so this is called a self-expanding valve.

We have three different manufacturers in our country;

  • Medtronic: Evolut R and Evolut R Pro models
  • Hydra Valve: Manufactured by Sajahanand Medical technologies
  • Portico Valve: Recently launched from Abbott group.

Now let us go to the question of which valve is best for a TAVR?

So many a times a patient who has been suggested a TAVR is given an option of a balloon expandable valve or a self-expanding valve.

So if one person is going for a balloon expandable valve or a self-expandable valve this critical decision can be made based upon the CT scan.

Before a TAVR procedure a CT scan is a mandatory test and it is essential for us to determine which type of valve is suitable for that particular person.

So on the CT scan what do the doctors look at?

The doctors look at the

  • Aortic valve type – Bicuspid versus Tricuspid
  • Diameter and area of the aortic valve
  • Perimeter of the aortic valve annulus
  • Calcium in aortic valve and adjacent locations
  • Peripheral vasculature – blood vessels for both lower limbs
  • Status of aorta

Based on these parameters the type of aortic valve – balloon versus self expanding would be determined. So there is really a little for a patient to choose as far as a balloon expandable or a self-expanding valve.

Advantages of new generation TAVR valves:

If the patient wants to gets the best valve for the TAVR procedure then he or she needs to choose a new generation of valve. New generation valves are those valves which are launched in last couple of years where these valves are superior, smaller profile and their complication rates are low.

The new generation valves are

  • SAPIEN 3 and SAPIEN Ultra from Edwards
  • Evolut R PRO from Metronic which are currently available in our country

So what is the advantage of the new generation of valves?

These new generation of valves tend to have a

  • Lesser need for pacemaker.
  • Lower chances for a para-valvular leak.
  • Other complications of the TAVR procedure is also much less.
  • These valves can be put through small groin incisions so one does not need a very large groin artery requirement for implantation.
  • Performance of these valves is much superior compared to the first generation of the Trans-catheter heart valve therapy.

Which valve is more durable? What is the durability of the TAVR valve?

There is lot of misconception that Surgical Valve is long lasting and TAVR valve is short lasting so that answer has been comprehensively found out from the recent clinical studies published in the last couple of years.

We all know TAVR is a new therapy, the existence of this new therapy is for past 10 to 12 years. So we have follow up data from patients’ at least 8 to 10 years indicating that the TAVR valve lasts as well as to that as surgical valve.

That means open heart surgery valve functioning and the TAVR valve were functioning equally at the end of 8 to 10 years in two different studies.

The advantage of TAVR valve over SAVR valve is people who had a TAVR valve tended to have a larger valve area, they tended to have a valve which is working for at least 10-15 years these patients tended to have a much better quality of life. They did have a complication rate similar to that of a surgical aortic valve. So indicating that TAVR is definitely equivalent to that of a surgical valve or in fact may be more better. The longevity beyond 10 to 12 years at the moment we do not have but I am sure with the progression of time duration of the TAVR valve I think progression of aortic valve narrowing again is much less.

Surgical Valve Replacement

Book Online Consultaion

    TAVR Valves – Which Valve is better? – Blog


    Subscribe the Hearty Life Blogs

      Dr raghu logo

      Dr raghu logo

      +91 95424 75650

      Call us now if you are in a medical emergency need, we will reply swiftly and provide you with a medical aid.

      Call us now if you are in a medical emergency need, we will reply swiftly and provide you with a medical aid.

      Dr. Raghu | Heart Specialist in Hyderabad
      Yashoda Hospitals, Sardar Patel Rd, behind Hari Hara Kala Bhavan, Kummari Guda, Shivaji Nagar, Secunderabad, Telangana 500003

      Best Cardiologists in Hyderabad

      Copyright © 2023, Dr. Raghu. All rights reserved.